Every Adopt Me value site compared: which one to trust

There are at least seven sites that will tell you what an Adopt Me pet is worth, and they do not agree. Not because some are lying, but because they measure different things: one counts what trades close at, one counts what people ask for, one counts demand votes, one is a marketplace. Here is what each one actually is, so you open the right one.

Elvebredd

The traffic leader, and the list most trading servers default to. Covers every pet with an exact number, has a calculator that adds those numbers, and has expanded into other Roblox games. Its strength is ubiquity: when both traders use it, the argument is over. Its weakness is the same one every numeric list has, false precision. We wrote a longer Elvebredd comparison if you want the detail.

Adopt Me Trading Values (AMTV)

AMTV calls itself the original values website for Adopt Me and it probably is. Its values are expressed in Ride Potions, which is an old convention from when potions were the unit of account, and the site is built around a W/F/L grid where you drop items on both sides. It also runs demand lists (hot, cold, unstable), rising and falling reports, user value suggestions and a logged-in trading area with auctions. Updated almost daily.

It is the most complete site for someone who trades seriously and wants the demand data behind a number. It is also the busiest interface in this list and expects you to create an account to use half of it.

AdoptMeValues.gg

Run under the Cosmic Values brand, AdoptMeValues.gg pairs a value list with a trade-ad board. You post what you have and what you want, rate the traders you deal with, and run offers through its calculator. Values come with a demand rating and pets are grouped into tiers, with categories like Exotic and Preppy pets. There is a Discord server and a Discord bot.

If your problem is finding a trading partner rather than checking a price, this is the more useful site. If you only want the price, the list is fine but you are wading through a marketplace to get to it.

123Demands

123Demands ranks pets by demand instead of price, which is a genuinely different signal. Demand is what tells you whether a pet will actually sell, and a high-value pet with low demand is a pet you will be stuck holding. It is a smaller site and the order it publishes is close to what everyone else publishes, but the framing is the point: it makes you ask whether anyone wants the pet, not just what a list says it is worth.

Traderie

Traderie is not a value list. It is a listings marketplace: players post the pet they are offering and the pets they want for it, and other players make offers. That makes it the only site in this list showing real asks instead of estimates. The catch is that asks are not closes. People list a Frost Fury for more than it trades at, always, and the site cannot tell you what the trade eventually settled for.

Use it to sanity-check a value list against what real people are asking. If a list says a pet is worth X and every Traderie listing wants 1.5X, the list is stale or the market is moving.

Happy Values

You will see "happy values" in trade chat and go looking for the site. There isn't one. The phrase means trading for pets that make you happy regardless of the list: paying over value for your dream pet and not caring. It is a legitimate way to play and an illegitimate way to be talked into a loss. If someone invokes happy values while offering you less than your pet is worth, they are describing your happiness, not theirs.

Why the numbers disagree

Put a Frost Fury into four of these sites and you get four numbers. That is expected. Each site samples a different slice of the market, weights Neon and potions differently, and updates on a different day. The market itself trades in bands, and a numeric value is a point picked inside a band.

Put the same Frost Fury next to a Kitsune on all four sites and the relationship is the same everywhere: close, Kitsune slightly ahead or slightly behind depending on the week. That relationship, the order, is the real information. It is what we publish as tiers on our Adopt Me value list, and it is why a trade that is fair by tier is fair on every site.

Which one to open

• Mid-trade, need a number both sides accept: Elvebredd.
• Want demand data and trend lists: AMTV.
• Want to post an offer and find a partner: AdoptMeValues.gg or Traderie.
• Not sure the pet will actually sell: 123Demands.
• Want to know if a trade is fair and why in ten seconds: our WFL calculator.

None of these sites are official. Adopt Me and its developer Uplift Games publish no values, and the trade window shows none. Every list, including ours, is a reading of the same community. The best habit is to check two, and to stop treating a three-point difference as a reason to decline.

FAQ